Guess what? I did exactly what I said I was going to do and it worked. I didn’t start over, I kept building on my previous story decisions and now I have my premise!
Yesterday I reviewed the main story ideas I had so far; the ones with the most energy. I ignored any pieces that didn’t fit well or stressed me out. Then to ease into things, I listed questions surrounding that core group of ideas. I still felt hopeless at the beginning, I’ll be honest, but writing down those unanswered questions was easy because those were the things that were overwhelming me. After a page or two of questions, I couldn’t help but start to answer them.
My first ideas weren’t always the best, but I was surprised how quickly more ideas came to take their place. Those ideas felt really good and they naturally fit with multiple elements of my story including some bits and pieces I had discarded earlier. Instead of focusing on the fear I felt about inventing science fiction elements and deciding on my main character, I allowed myself to brainstorm within that framework. The results were awesome.
In the evening, a cool twist popped into my head, fueled by all the other story decisions I had made. I think I may have actually said “Aha!” out loud when it hit me. Playing with that idea led me to reconsider aspects of my setting and timeline which produced a very nice story hook. Suddenly I knew where my story started, I knew the crisis and who experienced it. Just like that, I had defined my premise.
I recognize there is a lot more work to do, but I feel confident that this premise is the right place to start. I am so glad I didn’t give up.